Medical Forum
This not an emergency service, in case of a diving incident, please contact your local Coastguard, nearest recompression chamber or emergency services.
New Question
Specialist Forums > Medical Forum
Question
Posted : March 10, 2014
Why do we not impose mandatory medicals for ALL divers just as I have recently experienced in the Canaries. This cost 20 Euros and was reasonably basic and last for 2 years. Surely this would be good in the UK too?

Answer
Posted : March 11, 2014
Good question! Some countries have been doing this for some time, but I don't know of any evidence that they pick up any more problems than the targetted questionnaire approach. In the absence of access to medical records (which is usually the case), both methods still rely on the honesty and trustworthiness of the candidate diver, which cannot always be assumed.

The arguments for and against medical screening of divers have raged on for decades and there is no easy answer; in my view, any change to existing procedures needs to be backed up by good quality evidence, which as I've mentioned, is currently lacking.

Regards, Dr O
Answer provided by Dr Oliver Firth
Dr Ollie Firth
Additional Comment

Posted : March 11, 2014 by - Fine Wine
Thank you and as you say a lots is reliant on the honesty and trustworthiness of the diver but this is two fold; firstly the owe this much to themselves, family and oh the dive buddy. Secondly as I said originally the check up was quite basic, with BP, pulse ENT check and listening to breathing, then asked about wieght.
Well this all seems pretty straightforward and if some of these checks raised a concern with e.g. High BMI then surely a referral to a'specialist' dive medic would resolve any doubt.
I believe that most clubs/ organisations should push for this, what does anyone think???
Disclaimer:
The views expressed by Dr Firth & Dr Jules are their own and the publishers accept no liability for the advice and views expressed by Dr Firth , Dr Jules, or other users, which are provided as a general service to divers. Users are warned that secondary posts are the views of other users and may not be medically correct.
About us | Disclaimer & terms of use | Contact us | Site News | Suggestions | Link to us | Advertising Info
© 2006 Personal Print Ltd